2.0 is too weak, you should return the bulb and buy the 5.0.
And if your set up is only 16x16 it is WAY too small for three turtles. You need to look into getting a much larger set up. Ideally you want 10 gallons of water per inch of turtle shell.
2 RES: Leo (f) and Ezra (m)
1 Russian Tortoise: Godzilla (m)